The one thing that really appeals to me about fantasy gaming is the feeling of heroism at low levels. I love the gritty, real feeling you get when you don't have everything, you don't have much, magic is a mystery, and combat is deadly and dangerous, a serious choice you make as a last resort.
I have a lot of games, including some very nice ones like Tales of the Valiant that I want to play and that are fun, but I'm just not into that default superheroic level of fantasy that they provide. To me, it doesn't feel real at all to walk in with enough powers to handle any situation, and for certain classes like casters to have four different cantrips with infinite attack options at level one. There are almost too many options. When I am starting out, I just want to learn as I go, and I don't want that choice paralysis when the game starts.
I prefer a more grounded, almost GURPS-style 50-point basic character when I start and struggle to even complete basic attacks and fight for my life. Even if this means using sneaky or dirty tactics to win a fight, that's how you do things at the low end. Even a caster with one or two basic, almost magic-trick-type spells to choose from has to be very creative to use them effectively. I'm not getting infinite damage fire shots at level one. I have to be creative, struggle, and think about how I'm going to survive in a world that isn't that easy to survive in.
That, to me, is heroism.
Even if I am awarding 5-10 points per session in those early adventures to speed my characters up to the 250-point "hero standards," I like to collect powers and expand abilities naturally. I love the slow burn, naturally increasing my power level as I buy a few more skills or eventually earn Combat Reflexes; the feeling of growth in those early phases is what I treasure about fantasy gaming.
When it comes down to it, when I experience the hero's journey, which is what role-playing is to me, I want to see growth and change in a character. I don't want to follow a preset track where everything is decided ahead of time, and I know exactly what powers will be unlocked and at what level. I want my environment to shape who my character becomes. I don't know what skills or powers this person is going to buy. When they get character points, what I buy will reflect what they learned during the last adventure and session.
To me, fantasy gaming is more about growth and change. And I can't get excited about choices that are made for me. The only games that really appeal to me these days are the open-ended ones, the ones where you get character points, and you can do whatever you want with them. My thief in the alley with the dagger may steal a spellbook, and that is how he becomes, later on in life, the world's greatest archmage. I don't want to have everything planned out or have to decide who my character is before I begin. I love the blank sheet of paper that this game gives me.
This is more than the typical argument against Dungeons & Dragons 5E, where you get into fantasy superheroes, never dying, or ignoring exploration and survival mechanics. To me, 5E falls short because your entire life is planned out for you, with no surprise or discovery about who your character is. Once I get into multiclassing in 5E, that can provide some level of surprise, but more often than not, it results in a broken character who can't have any of the highest-level abilities once they make that choice. In 5E, I need to break the character in order to have discovery and choice. I will never get those level 20 abilities once I multiclass. Making a "for good reason" multiclass choice feels like a video game telling you you can't have something, and I really can't stand that.
The rules step in and artificially tell me, "No, you can't have that anymore."
Yes, this sounds a little frustrating. But I wrestle with those strict frameworks about what other designers think a paladin is, or how a thief or ranger should work. Many games still can't get the rogue or ranger right. They become poor choices compared to other classes, and I just want to give up when the design doesn't deliver on the fantasy or stacks up poorly. If a game strictly limits you to a suboptimal class design, I lose that choice as a real option, and the game feels broken.
Yes, GURPS is grittier and a lower power level. It can also be a higher power level than 5E, if you give people 500-point characters to start with. But I appreciate the low-level grit and difficulty, and all the settings I can tweak to make my game perfect and have the characters I want when I start. I can start with the 250-point experts of Dungeon Fantasy, or the "zero to hero" 50-point characters out of the core rules. I doubt many who play 5E understand how configurable GURPS really is, and they expect to walk in and have the game play "the one way the company designed it to" when that is just not the case with GURPS.
You can use a magic system, or just use superpowers with a magic power source for your special abilities. You can use multiple magic systems. Again, coming from 5E, things should work one way, right? Aren't the spell lists unified by divine, arcane, and wild? Where are the spell slots? How do I pick a subclass? Do I get my bonus action? For many, deciding "all this" while learning a new game is too much, so they go back to the familiar path of generic, standardized fantasy.
It is comfortable for me to run back there, too, but having my complete collection of 5E out and never playing it tells me I do not like that game or how it plays. I will have all eight shelves of 5E out here, and I will still be writing about GURPS. The frameworks that talented designers create are fun for most, but not engaging for me.
I need my character to be that blank sheet of paper.
I need my decisions to matter and to shape who this character becomes.




















