Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Why Science Fiction?

Remove the Star Frontiers, Star Wars, Star Trek, alien, and all the other franchise science fiction games, movies, and TV, and you do have a question. Why do we like science fiction? When I take away all of the fan-service science fiction, where I’m familiar with the universe, and I know what’s going on and I know how things work, it gets strange. You have the dystopian science fiction of Blade Runner, Alien, and a bunch of other hard science fiction IPs. You also have more positive, speculative science fiction, like Star Trek. You also have science fiction that copies another genre, like war movies or westerns; Star Wars fits here, and you could probably throw samurai movies in there as well.

Once I get rid of all of that, I have to ask myself that personal question: why I like science fiction in the first place. Without cultural reverence or familiarity to hang my hat on, I have to think hard about what, inside me, likes science fiction. There are parallels to the age of sail and discovery. You can throw movies about pirates and World War II in the mix, and science fiction becomes a way to safely explore familiar ideas from our history in a strictly nonhistorical setting where anything is possible.

Where fleet combats on the level of World War II, the Japanese Navy and the United States Navy slugging it out in the Pacific, are purely historical, and it’s a bit difficult to deviate from that history with your own stories, science fiction allows us to explore similar stories with open-ended conflicts and alternate histories that we can affect on our own. The same thing goes for westerns, samurai stories, and strange new world stories of exploration. Famous explorers all play into this genre. You can have a story about a famous brand-new alien planet, and we don’t know what’s on it; it’s only speculative. If you did that in a historical sense on Earth, you would know what was there because we’ve seen it all. In space, we have not seen it all. So our imaginations can run wild.

We can explore space and have those traditional swashbuckling or great explorer stories on our own, without having history weigh us down. I find that one of the things that appeals to me about science fiction is discovering the unknown. That is also why I like characters in GURPS: we don’t know how our characters are going to end up. We have no classes, no level tracks, no subclasses, and no powers we get on a schedule. Our character points are who we are, and the choices we make in how we spend them will build the character our experience creates.

When you meet an alien species that values something completely different from the human experience, it makes you question your own experiences and values. This is another thing I love about classic science fiction: it makes you think. If we come across an alien race that puts the highest value on the truth, and even things like euphemisms deeply upset them, or lying to protect someone’s feelings is seen as a grievous insult, it makes you think about those experiences in our lives and helps us reflect on who we are as humans and why we do the things we do.

I have to put away Star Frontiers for a while because that is steeped in nostalgia and memories for me. Star Frontiers is not why I like science fiction. It blends a number of pulp elements and dungeon crawls, along with hex crawling, that a lot of science fiction games today, especially the ones influenced by Mass Effect, totally miss. What I like about Star Frontiers is that it takes the familiar Traveller model of low-tech firearms, melee weapons, and primitive space technology, and it blends it with dungeon crawling in space. There was really only one great module series for the game. The Volturnus module series was the beginning and the end of Star Frontiers for us, because it was a John Carter-style romp through a world after a starship wreck forced you to explore and defend against evil aliens.

I loved that entire setup, and it is one of my fondest memories of science fiction gaming in my youth. The entire shipwrecked-on-a-new-world setup, where you have to deal with the aliens and unite them for a common defense, is a classic science fiction trope. It allows you to be the story’s hero. It’s not as cynical as Alien, and it’s not as overly political as Mass Effect. The adventure focuses on personal survival, with a heavy emphasis on social interaction as you meet different planetary races for the first time.

John Carter, Buck Rogers, and Flash Gordon share that classic “space hero” theme of the “Earthling out of water,” where the hero’s unique skills and point of view make them exceptional. It is a story based on the ideal of the larger-than-life figure who ends up doing amazing things in an unfamiliar environment, the Davy Crockett or John Henry sort of character. The Volturnus series also plays on this ideal, where characters from a multi-racial society help bring the unity that makes them strong to warring factions among the inhabitants of a new world. Instead of the individual as the exceptional figure, the ideal is the UPF and the greater society the four races built as they came together. You see that same theme in Star Trek, though modern writers often miss the point and forget the rules Roddenberry laid out for the universe, like the long-past need for money, the elimination of racial or gender animosity, and shortages never being a plot reason. The writers forget, since they want to tell today’s stories, and they fail at being Star Trek.

This is also why Dungeons & Dragons 5E and its creature-cantina-like collection of character races just deflates my interest in fantasy. It treats every new race as a strange shape, all the same, and none of them are special. None of them have any history; none of them have unique languages, philosophies, or a unique outlook on life. Great civilizations, literature, or famous figures? Nah. They’re all just funny-shaped humans with human attitudes, and cringeworthy excuses to make funny voices. The modern-fantasy collection of 1001 species in most games is terrible, with no real reason other than to provide silly shapes for human-like characters. Most of them are human-flavored stereotypes in latex masks.

Some science fiction settings cut out a huge amount of stories and put other flavors front and center. Good science fiction has to have a clear focus and use it to reflect on the human condition. Space dungeons are a weaker focus, but still fun; they do lack those larger questions of why we are here in the universe. The Jedi-Sith war feels overplayed and over, and the Force as a narrative tool is just “magic” these days instead of faith, the secrets of the universe, or anything meaningful. Alien is late-1970s corporate greed and dehumanization against the system. War themes are universal everywhere.

These days, science fiction, to me, mirrors my shift in interests away from modern fantasy and D&D, which all just seems so plain and pandering to a generic audience as a power fantasy. Remove the power fantasy as something that excites you, and what is left? A story about something external to your experience, and a deeper inner meaning it reflects.

Power fantasies, the bread and butter of modern storytelling, appeal to people as they feel more and more powerless in the real world. I don’t feel powerless, nor do I subscribe to the hopeless malaise of modern society and culture, which seems dependent on misery, anger, and hopelessness. Modern games are defined by the relationship between personal power and your ability to use it to cause violence, driven by frustration and a sense of lost agency in the real world. D&D teaches you that the only way out of your misery is 20 levels of increasing violence.

This was all said in the 1980s when I was growing up; don’t laugh. I heard it up and down that D&D was far too violent and forced aggressive answers to simple problems. That didn’t really change, and it is still true when you look at the game’s design. What is the modern designer’s answer to making Star Trek a compelling experience? Add more combat and violence. It was never supposed to be that way. The cerebral side of the genre is lost when all it becomes is cut-up aliens with laser swords, and you shoot them with energy weapons.

GURPS gives me the cerebral side of science fiction. I can play the scientist and have not a second of combat in my exploration mission, with close calls, alien encounters, lost ruins, and dangling from a vine above a 1000-foot gorge. What I learn through my skill rolls and mental logic will satisfy me more than a pile of dead aliens. This is part of why the oversimplified genres of science fiction, where it is dungeon crawling with laser pistols, do not appeal to me as much as the cerebral side.

I want something more. A deeper story and reflection of what it means to be alive. It can have action and adventure, but death and killing shouldn’t make up 90% of the genre for me.

I do long walks and talk to my AI assistant about these sorts of things, since my brother left the mortal realm years ago and I really have no one to bounce ideas off of, other than my AI and this blog. The reasons I play science fiction today, without him, are different from when we played together, and I have to come from a place deeply rooted in my perspective and what the genre means to me. I tried to rekindle my love of Star Wars recently, but that is something we played together, and it meant more for us to tell stories there than for me alone.

It is why I am searching for that great science fiction game. More than combat or space magic, more than making money or the hustle. I want something that feels real to me, that feels honest to me, and that reflects my inner self more than it does a surface feeling, power fantasy, or self-gratifying desire.

No comments:

Post a Comment